Sit inside an annual planning meeting at a $300 million company, and watch what happens the moment someone puts a genuinely sharp idea on the table.
Suppose a product leader speaks up: “Half the features on our roadmap only exist because procurement checklists ask for them. Nobody actually uses them. Let’s kill four of our secondary tools, fire our bottom tier of distracted enterprise accounts, and put everything we have behind the one workflow customers actually love us for.”
Watch the room go quiet. Nobody says the idea is wrong. Instead, a very polite, very expensive machine whirs to life.
The head of sales asks if there is third-party market sizing to prove enterprise buyers won’t churn. The CMO suggests pausing until next quarter so an outside research firm can run a six-week buyer survey. The CFO asks for a three-year spreadsheet showing the exact payback period before touching legacy revenue. By four o’clock, the sharp bet has been downgraded into a “Q3 exploratory workstream,” and the committee votes to give every department last year’s budget plus 4%.
Everybody walks out feeling responsible. Twelve months later, a hungrier competitor launches that exact narrow bet, steals their best accounts, and leaves the executive team wondering how thirty smart people in one room could miss what was sitting right in front of them.
Hollywood has lived with this riddle for a century. Before Star Wars opened in 1977, everyone at the studio thought it would bomb—including the cast and George Lucas himself. Studios severely underestimated Jaws, Titanic, Back to the Future, and Iron Man. Book publishing isn’t any sharper, even when the finished manuscript is sitting right on the editor’s desk. Twelve publishing houses rejected Harry Potter in 1995 because their numbers said it wouldn’t make money, and the thirteenth bought it expecting very little.
Screenwriter William Goldman explained why in three words: nobody knows anything. You know your own opinion, and everything past that is a guess. Other people’s minds are too strange, emotional, and personal to predict in advance—and not even modern algorithms can reliably figure out what humans will care about next.
Business strategy lives under the exact same law. Owning a clear place in a buyer’s mind is a bet on human behavior, not an engineering problem. You cannot prove an uncrowded position on a spreadsheet before you build it.
Most leadership teams are simply too scared to admit they are guessing. So instead of designing their company to win, they design their operating model, their org chart, and their capital rules to give everyone an alibi if they lose.
How fear shapes the org chart
For years, behavioural researcher Gerd Gigerenzer studied how senior managers inside large companies actually make high-stakes calls. He asked hundreds of executives a quiet question off the record: how often do you reject the option you genuinely believe is best for the company, and pick a weaker option you can defend on paper?
Again and again, leaders admitted they did it constantly. Gigerenzer called this defensive decision-making.
Think about the math of a modern executive career. Suppose a VP stakes $15 million of capital on an unproven, category-breaking position—refusing standard industry features so the company can own one radical promise. If that bet flops, the VP gets fired. There is nowhere to hide.
Now suppose that same VP copies the market leader’s roadmap, hires a big consulting firm to bless the slides, runs eight buyer focus groups, gets twelve VPs to co-sign the steering committee charter, and loses $40 million over two years as the product lands with a thud. Nobody gets fired. Everyone followed the process. The research firm said buyers wanted it. The committee agreed.
Once you see that incentive, the strange way big companies organize themselves suddenly makes total sense.
Why do enterprise companies route product and positioning choices through five layers of cross-functional sign-offs? Not because twelve insiders in a conference room produce sharper judgment—groups of insiders fall straight into groupthink, and almost none of them think like an actual buyer anyway. Committees exist to chop ownership into pieces small enough that blame can never land on one desk.
Why do boards let the highest-paid person in the room override months of front-line reality in ten minutes, or swing to the opposite extreme and spend $300,000 asking strangers in focus groups to vote on the future? Because if you ask the wrong people the wrong questions, focus groups will hand you a statistically confident chart pointing straight off a cliff—and you can staple that chart to your board deck as insurance.
Look closely at most org charts and governance routines. You are not looking at an operating model built to create market gravity. You are looking at an Alibi Machine.
Inherited operating models
People spend a lot of time worrying that humans are outsourcing their thinking to artificial intelligence, forgetting that we have outsourced our thinking to dead people for thousands of years. Ralph Waldo Emerson once wrote that almost everybody is just a quotation from their ancestors. Someone with authority tells us how the world is supposed to run, so we repeat it as gospel.
The philosopher Hilary Lawson has a sharp name for this habit: living under a dead closure.
A closure is simply how you frame and use a piece of the messy world in front of you. Hand a pencil to three people: an artist frames it as a drawing tool, a writer frames it as a word tool, and an angry kid frames it as a weapon to stab into drywall. Positioning is closure. It is choosing what your company means—and refusing every other use.
A closure turns “dead” the moment you follow a rule solely because you watched somebody else do it first. Individuals shuffle into jobs, marriages, and political shouting matches just because it is the next choreographed step handed to them by parents, newspapers, or peers.
Companies build their entire operating models out of dead closures:
- Capital allocation on autopilot: Every autumn, finance hands each division roughly what it got last year, +/- five percent, starving the breakthrough bet to keep fading business units comfortable.
- Copycat org design: A rival hires a Chief AI Officer or splits sales into three enterprise pods, and within six months four competitors copy the exact same reporting lines without asking what problem it solves.
- Borrowed product rules: Every vendor in a software category stuffs the same 300 checklist features into their platform because “enterprise RFPs require them,” turning the entire industry into overpriced wallpaper.
Blindly repeating industry tradition is a trap, and chasing shiny novelty just to look different is a trap too. When your operating model runs on borrowed scripts, you never make the costly refusals required to stand for one thing. You spend millions building a slightly blurrier version of the company across the street.
Three times the spreadsheet said “no”
If you want to see how badly the Alibi Machine fails at predicting human value, look at three moments where every conventional research tool, playbook, and committee screamed to walk away.

1. The chair nobody wanted to sit in
In the early 1990s, executives inside office furniture giant Herman Miller knew something was changing in how Americans worked, yet every rule in their industry followed a dead script. Office chairs came upholstered in thick foam and fabric. Big bosses got tall leather thrones; junior staff got cheap cloth pads.
Designers Bill Stumpf and Don Chadwick brought back something strange: a stripped-down chair made of stretched black pellicle mesh with zero foam, zero fabric, and exposed mechanical ribs that looked like an insect skeleton.
Herman Miller ran the prototypes through standard consumer testing. The scores didn’t just disappoint—they cratered. Test subjects hated how it looked, didn’t trust that thin mesh could hold their weight, and gave comfort ratings around 4.75 out of 10, well below the 7.5 score Herman Miller normally demanded before funding factory tooling. Facility managers warned it would ruin the prestige of executive floors.
Under a defensive operating model, the Aeron chair dies right there in that binder. Instead, leadership looked closer at why the room reacted that way: testers sat for two minutes looking for plush couch softness, completely missing how foam traps body heat over an eight-hour workday.
Herman Miller refused to upholster the chair to please the focus group, bet millions on custom manufacturing tooling, and launched it naked. The Aeron became the bestselling, highest-margin icon in office history—and sits in the Museum of Modern Art’s permanent collection.

2. The retail store with no commissioned salespeople
Walk into a traditional electronics or computer store in the year 2000, and the operating model was set in stone: stack brown boxes to the ceiling, locate in cheap suburban strip malls, and pay floor staff sales commissions so they push warranties and clear old inventory.
When Apple decided to open its own retail stores in 2001, retail experts and Wall Street analysts treated it like corporate suicide. BusinessWeek ran an infamous piece titled “Sorry, Steve: Here’s Why Apple Stores Won’t Work.” Gateway had already tried computer stores and failed miserably.
Look at the refusals baked into Apple’s store design and operating model. Instead of cheap strip-mall rent, they signed terrifying leases on the most expensive main streets in the world. Instead of cramming fifty brands onto shelves, they left three-quarters of the floor open so strangers could play with four product lines for hours.
Most importantly, they refused to pay floor staff sales commissions—hiring “Geniuses” whose explicit job rule was to help solve a customer’s problem even if that meant telling them not to buy a new computer today.
No historical retail spreadsheet could justify paying Fifth Avenue rent for an uncommissioned help desk. Yet by refusing to optimize square footage for fast box-moving, Apple built the highest sales-per-square-foot retail engine on earth.

3. The rental site that killed its own late fees
At the turn of the century, Blockbuster sat on nearly 9,000 stores and billions in cash flow. Hidden inside its ledger, though, was an operating addiction: roughly $800 million a year (around 16% of its revenue) came from charging customers late fees when they returned a tape a day late.
In 2000, a tiny, bleeding mail-order startup called Netflix flew to Dallas and offered to sell itself to Blockbuster for $50 million. On a defensive CFO’s spreadsheet, laughing Netflix out of the building was the only logical move. DVD-by-mail lost money, served a tiny niche of movie buffs, and worst of all, Netflix had just moved to a flat monthly subscription with zero late fees.
Think about what matching Netflix would have required inside Blockbuster’s org chart. Franchise owners and regional VPs depended on those $800 million in late-fee penalties to hit their quarterly bonuses. Refusing late fees meant blowing up their own store economics and firing their favourite profit line before subscription streaming had proven it could pay the bills.
Blockbuster chose the safe spreadsheet. Ten years later, Blockbuster filed for bankruptcy, while the $50 million outlier they rejected marched past $100 billion.

The ledger nobody audits
Every time an executive committee sits down to allocate capital, there are two ways to be wrong.
The first mistake is funding a bet you think will win, watching it flop in public. Statisticians call that a false positive.
The second mistake is starving or killing an uncomfortable bet because you assume it won’t work—and watching someone else ride that exact truth to own your market. That is a false negative.
Corporate accounting is obsessed with the first mistake and completely blind to the second.
If a division head spends $3 million building a bold new product wedge and it fails, finance tracks every penny in red ink. The post-mortem goes onto the board agenda. Careers get bruised.
Now ask where the CFO records the loss when a steering committee waters down a category-defining bet, starves an outlier team to fund six mediocre legacy products, or rejects a no-late-fee model to protect this quarter’s bonus pool. Nowhere. There is no line on an income statement for The Cost of Playing It Safe.
Executives, investors, and VPs sit at the head of tables acting as gatekeepers every single week—judging roadmaps, cutting weird ideas, demanding “more proof” before shifting resources. Yet almost nobody keeps score on the gatekeepers.
Do you actually track your own batting average? How many “safe,” consensus-approved launches did your leadership team greenlight over the last three years that customers met with a shrug? And how many uncomfortable refusals did your room talk itself out of—only to watch a smaller, braver rival claim that exact territory two years later?
Nobody bats a thousand when human beings are on the other side of the transaction. Pretending your committees aren’t guessing doesn’t eliminate risk. It just trades visible flops for a slow, polite slide into irrelevance.
Replacing alibis with firsthand conviction
If focus groups lie, industry playbooks trap you in dead scripts, and committees sand off every sharp edge, how does a CEO actually find the spine to rewire the company?
Watch the rare founders and chief executives who consistently make sharp, non-obvious bets, and you notice a distinct habit of mind. They have zero interest in summary slides filtered through four layers of middle management, and they feel deeply disconnected sitting in polished conference rooms trading corporate buzzwords.
Instead, they have an insatiable appetite to understand how real people actually think. They go down rabbit holes late at night connecting ideas from psychology, history, and unrelated industries. More importantly, they sit directly across from customers and front-line dissenters—not to pitch them or hand them a multiple-choice survey, but to uncover what shaped their worldview, why they believe what they believe, and what frustrates them that they have stopped bothering to complain about. They ask one plain question after another until both people are questioning every assumption their industry treats as sacred.
Firsthand curiosity does what no focus group ever can: it gives a leader earned conviction. Once you have seen a human truth with your own eyes—that office workers overheat in foam, that buyers hate commissioned pushiness, that late fees breed quiet resentment—you no longer need a committee to hold your hand.
That is when positioning moves out of the marketing slides and cuts straight into how the company runs:
- Audit your Missing Graveyard. Pull the notes from your last two annual planning cycles. List the three boldest, most uncomfortable bets your leadership team killed or starved because “the data wasn’t there yet”. Ask out loud: did we kill those because they were wrong for the buyer, or because no single executive wanted their name on the risk?
- Break one inherited rule in your operating model. Pick the most sacred “that’s just how our industry works” habit inside your business—how you bill, how you staff support, what features you refuse to build, or which customers you turn away. Step outside your bubble and ask whether you actually chose that model yourself, or inherited it from competitors you claim to be beating.
- Take away the committee’s veto. Strip consensus sign-offs out of your core bet. Put one obsessed builder directly in front of real customers, protect their capital from legacy turf wars, and give them explicit permission to break the old category script.
Any rival with fifty thousand dollars and a free weekend can copy the words on your homepage. None of them will copy an operating model that requires dismantling their own Alibi Machine.
Stop asking a survey to give you courage you haven’t earned yourself. Go talk to real humans until you find a truth worth betting your org chart on—and start keeping score of what playing it safe is really costing you.




Leave a Reply