Introduction

Why I wrote this
Too many leadership teams keep changing logos, websites, and campaigns yet feel stuck in the same competitive mud. I see wasted budgets, confused employees, and customers who shrug. The fault isn’t creativity. It’s a missing bridge between inside decisions and outside perception. I wrote this guide to build that bridge.

Who it’s for
Founders and CEOs of growth-stage or enterprise businesses who carry profit-and-loss responsibility and must defend or grow market share. If you sign off on strategy, budget, or culture, this is your brief.

What you’ll get

• A simple 4-Level Positioning map that links what you say, prove, live, and be.
• Roger L. Martin’s strategy-as-choice checklist to keep claims tied to real trade-offs.
• Chris Argyris’ double-loop questions to stop you locking into stale assumptions.
• Concrete leadership actions: what to fund, what to kill, and what to hard-wire into the business model.

What you’ve already tried
You’ve likely:

• Rebranded (again).
• Hired agencies to “fix the messaging.”
• Loaded dashboards with NPS, CAC, OKRs.
• Run culture workshops that never reached the front line.

Results: minor bumps, no moat. Competitors continue to copy your language and undercut your prices.

Why this is different
This approach does not start with marketing. It starts with one noun you choose to own, backed by costly moves, systems, and a learning loop that questions itself before the market does. It turns positioning from a slogan into an operating system. If you’re ready to anchor every decision to a single mental territory, read on.

Inside-Out vs. Outside-In — Positioning as the Bridge

Every great business strategy has two perspectives. Inside-out (IQ) is the view from the boardroom: your internal plan, products, and operational decisions. Outside-in (EQ) is the view from the market: how customers emotionally perceive and experience your brand. These are two sides of the same coin.

The trouble is, many leadership teams treat them separately. The result? A strategy that makes sense on paper but doesn’t resonate externally, or bold branding that isn’t rooted in internal reality. 

Positioning is the bridge between IQ and EQ. It links who you are internally with what you represent in your customer’s mind. In other words, positioning aligns business strategy with brand perception, ensuring that every internal decision reinforces a concept that your customers feel.

Think of positioning as owning a singular idea (often a noun) in the mind of your market. It’s not just a marketing tagline, it’s the mental territory you stake out and commit to becoming.

Positioning is not a marketing exercise. It is the atomic core of business strategy, guiding both what you say and what you do. Done right, positioning translates a CEO’s inside-out vision into an outside-in story that customers believe, because the business proves and lives it at every level.

Strategy as Choice: Martin’s Cascade Under the Hood

Roger L. Martin argues that strategy is a set of five interlocking choices:

1. Winning aspiration – why we exist
2. Where to play – the playing field
3. How to win – the advantage we’ll claim
4. Capabilities – what we must be great at
5. Management systems – how we’ll reinforce the above choices

I’ve mapped those choices to the 4-Level Positioning Framework (which I created):

Choice	Primary Positioning Level(s) Affected	Comment
Winning aspiration	Level 1 (Saying It)	Sets the public claim.
Where to play / How to win	Level 2 & 3 (Proving / Living It)	Evidence and costly actions show the field and advantage.
Capabilities & Systems	Level 4 (Being It)	Business model, culture, incentives, all engineered to keep winning.

Why it matters: Without explicit choices, a Level-1 tagline floats with no support. Positioning gains power only when each of Martin’s five choices pulls in the same direction.

The Four Levels of Positioning

To build that bridge from internal strategy to external perception, your positioning must be embedded at multiple levels of the business. We can think in terms of a 4-Level Positioning Framework (sometimes referred to as the 4-Level Positioning Canvas: Surface, Evidence, Action, System).

Each level represents a deeper degree of commitment: from the superficial claims any company can make, down to the hard-to-replicate core of your business model. Below are the four levels, what they mean, and how leadership can drive alignment at each one.

Double-Loop Learning: Keeping the Positioning Honest

Chris Argyris distinguishes between two kinds of organizational learning:

• Single-loop: fix errors without questioning core assumptions.
• Double-loop: challenge and revise the governing beliefs that created the errors.

Applied to positioning:

Learning Mode	Typical Result	Positioning Impact
Single-loop	“Let’s improve the metric.”	Tweaks Level 2 evidence, leaves core idea untouched.
Double-loop	“Should we change the premise?”	Can spark Level 3 sacrifices or even a Level 4 model shift.

Leadership move: Build forums, after-action reviews, pre-mortems, ‘red-team’ sessions, where teams are safe to question the winning aspiration itself. That prevents rigid adherence to an outdated position and surfaces fresh choices when markets shift.

Level 1: Saying It – Surface Claims and Taglines

This is the surface level of positioning: what you say you are. It includes your taglines, slogans, and one-liner claims about your company. At Level 1, a leadership team articulates a value proposition or mission, essentially planting a flag with words. For example, a SaaS startup might declare, “We are the future of finance,” or a retailer claims to be “customer-obsessed.” These statements are important because they set the initial narrative. However, they’re easy to create and easy to copy. Any competitor can echo similar slogans overnight. In other words, Level 1 positioning is instantly replicable and low-cost, which means it rarely differentiates you for long.

Think of the countless companies that tout “innovative solutions” or “world-class customer service” on their websites. Simply saying it doesn’t make it true or unique. For instance, in the early days of e-commerce, Amazon proclaimed itself “Earth’s most customer-centric company.” That bold claim (Level 1) set a direction, but on its own, it was just words that any retailer could have used. The value of a Level 1 claim comes only if it’s backed by the deeper levels to follow.

Leadership Actions at Level 1: For CEOs and founders, the task here is to clarify and focus the message and prepare to back it up.

Key actions include:

• Fund the development of a clear, noun-based tagline or mantra that captures your core idea (e.g. Amazon = “customer-centricity”). Invest time in word choice that reflects a concept you truly intend to own.
• Stop using fluffy adjectives and empty superlatives. If your positioning statement sounds like it could fit any company in your industry, it’s not distinctive. Avoid clichés like “leading provider of…” without substance behind them.
• Prioritize internal alignment on this claim. Ensure every leader on your team understands what you’re claiming and why. Before broadcasting a tagline, ask each other: “Is this the one thing we want to stand for above all?” If not, refine it.
• Delegate the polishing of slogans to marketing, but own the core idea at the leadership level. The CEO’s job is to define the mental territory; copywriters can wordsmith, but they must not stray from the concept you’ve chosen to claim.

Level 2: Proving It – Evidence and Proof Points

At Level 2, you move from talk to evidence. It’s about backing up your claims with facts, data, and third-party validation. This includes metrics, case studies, testimonials, awards, and other proof points that show you can deliver on what you say. If Level 1 is “Trust us, we do X,” then Level 2 is “Here’s the proof – we actually do X.”

Consider how Apple backs up its product quality with evidence like industry-leading customer satisfaction ratings and millions of loyal repeat customers. Or how Amazon proves “customer-centricity” by publishing stats on delivery speeds and customer service ratings.

Enterprise software companies often claim to empower productivity (Level 1), and then demonstrate it by sharing case studies (e.g. “Client X saw a 30% efficiency boost using our tool”) and testimonials from happy clients (Level 2). These proof points are harder for competitors to deny, but they’re still moderately easy for a rival to match — after all, anyone can cherry-pick some good metrics or get a customer quote. Level 2 builds credibility, yet it’s not a durable moat by itself.

Leadership Actions at Level 2: Here, the leadership team’s role is to gather and broadcast proof of the positioning:

• Fund the capabilities that generate proof. This might mean investing in analytics to track key metrics, customer success programs to produce case studies, or independent audits (e.g. sustainability reports) to verify your claims. For example, if you position on “reliability,” fund rigorous quality testing and publish those results.
• Stop hiding from inconvenient data. Embrace transparency. If some metrics are weak, don’t just spin a new tagline — improve the product. Also, stop using vanity metrics; focus on evidence that genuinely matters to your core promise.
• Prioritize the proof points in external communications. Make sure sales and marketing teams lead with quantifiable results and real stories, not just adjectives. As a leader, celebrate evidence internally too. Recognize teams for wins that reinforce your chosen position (e.g. improved NPS, notable client success).
• Delegate evidence-gathering but own the standards. You might delegate customer research and PR outreach for reviews or awards, but leadership must set the standard for what “good proof” looks like. Ensure the chosen metrics and testimonials truly reflect your core position (quality, speed, innovation, etc.), rather than random positive stats.

Level 3: Living It – Costly Actions and Decisions

Level 3 is where positioning leaps from paper into practice. Living it means making bold decisions that cost real money or require sacrifice in order to authentically stand for your chosen idea. At this level, leadership decisions become proof of values. It’s no longer just about what you say or show. It’s what you’re willing to give up or invest in to live your positioning. These are the famous stories and moves that signal to the world (and your team) that you mean it. Because they often involve short-term cost or risk, they’re hard for competitors to copy casually.

A classic example is Patagonia. They have long positioned themselves around environmental responsibility. At Level 1, Patagonia’s tagline was, “We’re in business to save our home planet.” Nice words, but Patagonia didn’t stop there. At Level 3, they famously took out a “Don’t Buy This Jacket” ad on Black Friday, urging customers to buy less. This counterintuitive move cost them potential sales in the short run, but it proved their commitment to sustainability. It was a costly action that lived their values.

Similarly, Costco is positioned on delivering value to customers. One seemingly small but emblematic decision is that Costco has never raised the price of its hot dog combo beyond $1.50 for decades. Keeping that price so low cuts into profits, but it sends a loud message: we sacrifice margin to stay true to our value promise. Leaders at Costco literally said they’d rather change suppliers than ever charge more for the hot dog. It’s become a symbol of their positioning.

Even tech companies have their Level 3 moments. Tesla, whose position centers on the “future” and sustainable innovation, open-sourced its electric vehicle patents in 2014. Elon Musk gave away valuable IP (a costly decision) to accelerate the adoption of EVs (aligning with Tesla’s mission to transition the world to sustainable energy). That was not a marketing stunt; it was strategy living the positioning.

In the same vein, Zappos built its brand on customer happiness, to the extent that it encouraged call center reps to spend hours on the phone with customers without any pressure to rush. The late CEO Tony Hsieh famously said he wanted customer service to be the company’s main product, not shoes. In one case, a Zappos rep stayed on a customer call for 10 hours 43 minutes, setting a record while solving the customer’s issue and bonding with them. That kind of “whatever it takes” service is a costly choice most companies wouldn’t allow, but it proved Zappos truly lived its “deliver happiness” positioning. These examples all illustrate Level 3: leadership making purposeful sacrifices or investments to demonstrate what the company stands for.

Leadership Actions at Level 3: Living it requires courage and long-term thinking from the top. At this level, leaders should:

• Fund the initiatives that put money where your mouth is. This could mean allocating budget to something like higher-quality materials despite lower margins, or extra customer service staff despite higher costs, wherever you can make a decision that shows your values in action. Consider these expenditures strategic investments in your brand equity.
• Stop doing things that contradict your positioning, even if they’re profitable in the short term. This might be the hardest part. For example, if your brand stands for privacy, stop selling user data or nix an ad targeting tactic, even if it brings revenue. If you stand for quality, don’t launch a cheap sub-par product line to chase quick sales. Leaders must be willing to say no to opportunities that conflict with their core position.
• Prioritize symbolic moves that galvanize your team and customers around your purpose. Ask, “What’s our version of the $1.50 hot dog?” A decision so aligned with your identity that altering it would undermine who we are. Highlight these choices in company communications and culture. When Patagonia’s founders encouraged repairing clothes and reselling used gear, they reinforced to employees and customers: we mean what we say about the environment. Determine what action for your company would send a similar signal, and make it a priority, not an afterthought.
• Delegate carefully, if at all. Level 3 decisions often can’t be fully delegated because they may contradict normal financial logic. The CEO and leadership team must lead by example here. However, you can delegate the execution of these bold initiatives to empowered teams. For instance, empower a sustainability team to identify costly changes in the supply chain that align with your ethos, but top management must back them when trade-offs arise. In short, protect your team’s ability to make principle-over-profit decisions by backing them at the highest level.

Level 4: Being It – Business Model and Core Identity

Level 4 is the ultimate positioning commitment: your company’s entire business model and systems are engineered around one core concept. At this level, the positioning isn’t just a part of your strategy – it is your strategy. You become the noun you set out to own. Everything from your product design, to revenue model, to culture and values is built to reinforce a singular idea in the market. Achieving Level 4 means your competitive advantage is woven into your organizational DNA – which makes it nearly impossible for competitors to copy without completely transforming themselves. It’s your mental monopoly, your unique territory.

The most iconic companies in the world play at Level 4. Amazon, for example, is synonymous with “convenience.” Jeff Bezos didn’t just add convenience as a tagline. He redesigned the entire business around it. Amazon Prime’s free two-day shipping (now often one-day or same-day) was not profitable at first, but it fit the convenience mission. The company built an unmatched logistics system, one-click purchasing, and a marketplace for virtually everything, all to own the territory of fastest, easiest service. That’s business-model positioning: any rival wanting to match Amazon’s convenience would have to duplicate its vast fulfillment network and customer-first culture — a tall order. 

Tesla is similarly a Level 4 player. Tesla’s core concept might be described as “the future” (or “innovative sustainable technology”). Yes, Tesla has great taglines and proof points like glowing reviews, but more importantly, Tesla operates differently than a traditional car company. They sell direct to consumers, build gigafactories, integrate energy storage and solar – all elements of a new model of automotive and energy business. The entire company is architected to deliver the future of transportation and energy, not just cars. 

Apple is often cited here too: Apple’s positioning around superior user experience and design isn’t just ad-speak. Their closed ecosystem, hardware-software integration, obsessive product development process, retail stores, and even pricing all reinforce Apple’s “experience” stance. As a result, when you buy an Apple product, the experience feels different by design. These companies have aligned their internal systems so tightly with their external promise that the two are inseparable. Their brand is their business.

Even smaller companies can aspire to Level 4. For instance, sustainable shoe maker Allbirds positions on eco-friendly innovation. At Level 3, we saw them take costly action by open-sourcing their sustainable foam technology for others to use (sacrificing a competitive edge to push the industry forward). At Level 4, Allbirds’ entire business model centers on lowering carbon footprint – from material sourcing, to manufacturing, to how they sell and even how they encourage recycling. That core mission drives every decision. A competitor that wanted to beat Allbirds on “most sustainable footwear” would have to overhaul their own supply chain and ethos to match this systemic commitment.

Leadership Actions at Level 4: Attaining “Being it” is a continuous leadership challenge. It means institutionalizing your positioning:

• Fund the infrastructure and model that deliver your core promise at scale. This might involve major capital decisions (factories, logistics, technology platforms) or organizational design choices (e.g. subscription model vs. one-time sales, if your position is about ongoing service). Essentially, double down on assets that differentiate your concept. Amazon built warehouses and AWS; Tesla invests in battery R&D and charging stations – these big bets enable their positions. Figure out what foundational investments your noun requires, and finance them.
• Stop any line of business, process, or tradition that dilutes your focus. Level 4 often requires painful focus. It could mean divesting a profitable unit that doesn’t fit the story. Leaders at Netflix, for example, famously decided to stop its DVD-by-mail service and go all-in on streaming, effectively reinventing the model around “on-demand entertainment.” That was aligning the whole business to a vision (and it paid off). Be willing to shed things that don’t align with the one territory you want to own.
• Prioritize coherence in every department. This is where cross-functional leadership is critical. Use the positioning as a litmus test for initiatives in product development, hiring, budgeting, even OKR setting. Ask, “How does this decision reinforce what we want to own in the market?” At Level 4, strategic clarity is culture. Leadership should over-communicate the core concept so that employees at every level can make day-to-day choices that align. Make that concept the North Star in planning sessions. For example, if your noun is “simplicity,” your product roadmap, your marketing copy, and your pricing scheme – all should be relentlessly simplified.
• Delegate execution but not vision. As CEO, you cannot hand off Level 4 alignment and assume it will happen. You must lead it. However, you can delegate authority to guardians of the vision in various teams. Identify evangelists internally who deeply “get” the positioning and empower them to veto or modify initiatives that stray off-course. Create systems of accountability where major decisions are checked against the core idea. In practice, this might mean setting up a leadership committee or a Chief Positioning Officer role (formally or informally) that oversees strategic coherence. Ultimately, though, consistency starts from the top – every executive should model and reinforce the focus.

Leadership and Coherence: Making the Positioning Stick

One theme should be clear from the four levels: alignment. A positioning strategy only delivers market differentiation if leadership ensures coherence across all levels of the organization. It’s not enough to have a clever tagline (Level 1) if your business model (Level 4) doesn’t support it. In fact, misalignment is worse than having no positioning at all. It breeds customer distrust and internal confusion. Leaders must drive a unified direction so that what you say at the surface matches what you are at the core.

Strategic clarity isn’t just about messaging; it’s about the internal choices that reinforce a single mental territory over time. If you claim one thing but fund another, people notice. If you prove some points but shy away when it’s costly, competitors will mimic your surface and outperform you underneath. On the flip side, when all four levels line up, you carve out a space in the market that’s yours alone.

Real competitive advantage lives at Levels 3 and 4.

If you’re constantly worried about competitors stealing your ideas or copycatting your marketing, it’s a sign you’re stuck at the shallow levels. The solution is to deepen your commitment. Make bolder moves, embed the idea into your operations and rise to a level they can’t easily copy.

Coherence is a leadership responsibility. It requires saying no to good ideas that don’t fit, and doubling down on the great idea that defines you. It means using the same lens for every decision: Does this strengthen the position we want in customers’ minds, or distract from it? 

When a company achieves this unity of purpose, customers feel it. The brand seems singular, clear, and trustworthy. Internally, employees have a guiding star for autonomy. They know “this is how we do things here” because leadership consistently models it. The CEO and team essentially create a mental monopoly around a concept, and everyone from product engineers to sales reps knows the concept by heart.

Putting It Together

1. Make the choices visible. Document Martin’s five choices on one page.
2. Test them with double-loop questions. What if our “where to play” is wrong? What belief drives that choice?
3. Align each choice to a positioning level. If a choice does not reinforce the noun you’re claiming, rewrite it or change the noun.
4. Institutionalize the review. Re-run the cascade + double-loop check every planning cycle. Markets move; so must your assumptions.

Conclusion – Audit, Choose, Learn

• Audit your four levels.
• Choose with Martin’s cascade. Explicit choices turn slogans into strategy.
• Learn with Argyris’ double loop. Question assumptions before the market does.

Ask again: What noun do we truly own, and which choice would we rethink if that noun stopped winning tomorrow? If you can answer fast (and act), you’re ready to keep your positioning both coherent and alive.

For CEOs and founders, the 4-Level Positioning Framework I created is not just a marketing exercise; it’s a mirror for your business. Take a hard look and audit your company across these four levels.

Ask yourself and your leadership team:

• Are we just saying it, or also proving it, living it, and being it? Identify where you are strong and where you’re falling short. If you have great messaging but no defining actions, you know where to focus next. If you’ve made bold moves but haven’t woven them into the business model, figure out how to systematize them.
• What noun do we truly own? Can you distill your strategy into a single concept that you want to dominate in the customer’s mind? If you struggle to answer, you likely have a positioning gap.
• What would break if we stopped believing in it? In other words, what’s your $1.50 hot dog decision, the thing so tied to your identity that abandoning it would hurt your business? If nothing comes to mind, your supposed “position” might just be lip service.

Use these questions as your guide. Be brutally honest. The goal is to reach a point where everything your company does – from top-level strategy to daily operations – consistently tells the same story. When you achieve that alignment, you’re not just differentiated in the market; you’re virtually inimitable. And that is the ultimate strategic advantage.

Now is the time to ensure your inside-out IQ and outside-in EQ are in sync. Gather your leadership team and map your four levels. Decide what you will claim, prove, live, and ultimately be. In doing so, you’ll stake out a lasting position that drives both business alignment and market differentiation for years to come.

Ask yourself: What noun do we truly own? What would break if we stopped believing in it? Answer those, and you’ll know what to do next.

Need help with positioning and owning your category?

Start here → claritytoscale.biz