A $1.50 hot dog does more positioning than a $150k rebrand. Costco hasn’t budged that price tag since 1985, and it screams one word more loudly than any copywriter ever could: VALUE.
After fifteen years of fielding objections about “positioning,” two patterns repeat:
- Messaging masquerading as positioning.
- This won’t work in my niche: B2B SaaS, solopreneur, you name it.
Both objections confuse gravity with glitter. Let’s dismantle them.
1. Position ≠ Messaging: The Gravity-Well Model
- Position is the dense mass at your company’s core.
- Messaging is the light reflecting off orbiting moons (products, ads, UI choices, your LinkedIn headline).
Stakeholders may describe you in wildly different words, yet they’ll still orbit the same invisible center, if the mass is real.
2. The Four Levels of Positioning
Level | What It Means | Copyability | Cost / Risk |
---|---|---|---|
1 — Saying It | Taglines, slogans, “I help X do Y” sentences | Instant | Cheap |
2 — Proving It | Testimonials, metrics, case studies | Moderate | Low |
3 — Being It | Decisions that cost real money (Costco hot dog, Patagonia “Don’t Buy This Jacket”) | Hard | High |
4 — Owning It | Business model engineered around one mental territory. Amazon = Convenience, Tesla = Future, Apple = Experience | Nearly impossible | Existential |
If you fear copycats, you’re living at Level 1 or 2.
3. Three Mini-Case Studies
(Quick Reference. From Position to “I help…”)
Example | Position (Core Concept, Level 4) | What | Niche (Who Feels It Most) | USP / Edge | Sample “I help…” Line |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Superman | HOPE | Immediate rescue from existential threats | Citizens of Metropolis in mortal danger | Faster‑than‑light response, super strength | “I help endangered civilians survive existential threats with super‑powered rescue.” |
HubSpot | INBOUND | All‑in‑one CRM & marketing automation that scales relationships | SMBs & mid‑market B2B companies trying to grow without enterprise budgets | Freemium entry; unified platform; inbound methodology | “We help scaling businesses attract, engage, and delight customers with an all‑in‑one inbound growth platform.” |
Nike | HUMAN POTENTIAL | Gear that unlocks the athlete inside everyone | Everyday and elite athletes who aspire to personal bests | Performance tech fused with cultural relevance | “We help athletes of every level smash personal records with performance‑driven gear.” |
Notice how the “I help…” statements sit in Level 1, far above the gravitational core.
4. Run This AUDIT on Your Brand
- One-Word Stress Test – Reduce your strategy to a single noun.
- Balance-Sheet Proof – Where do you spend money that a copycat would hate to match?
- Orbit Map – Ask employees, customers, and investors for a one-sentence description. Do their answers cluster?
- Copycat Cost Estimate – If a rival could mimic you with <3 weeks and <$50k, dig deeper.
- Message Lag Check – If operations evolved but the website copy hasn’t changed in six months, update the words, not the core.
5. Put It to Work
Your editable 4-Level Positioning Canvas (below) shows the three examples above. Copy this into your Google Docs, duplicate the blank column, plug in your own data, and see which cells feel flimsy. If Level 3 or 4 is empty, that’s tomorrow’s agenda.
My challenge to you: What’s your $1.50 hot dog? The decision aligns so closely with your core that changing it would disrupt the business? Drop your answer (or your canvas screenshot) in the comments. Let’s see who’s ready to bend the market, not just the copy.
Positioning 4‑Level Canvas
How to Use
Fill each cell for your own brand. The three columns are pre‑populated with example answers for Superman (individual hero), HubSpot (B2B SaaS), and Nike (consumer brand) so you can see what “good” looks like.
Level | Definition | Superman | HubSpot | Nike |
---|---|---|---|---|
1 — Saying It | Public claims, slogans, taglines | “Champion of Truth & Justice.” | “Grow Better.” | “Just Do It.” |
2 — Proving It | Evidence, case studies, measurable results | Global news footage of rescues; citizens’ testimonials | Customer case studies, ROI metrics, HubSpot Academy success stories | Athlete records, endorsements, customer reviews |
3 — Being It | Decisions that cost real money/time/risk | Sacrifices personal life; always answers distress calls; refuses political power | Freemium CRM; heavy investment in free education; conferences that teach inbound for free | Billions in R&D for performance tech; backs activist athletes; refuses to abandon social‑impact stands |
4 — Owning It | Entire business model bends around a single mental territory | Owns HOPE | Owns INBOUND GROWTH | Owns HUMAN POTENTIAL |
Highly recommend starting with the CEO Clarity Kit before doing this canvas. The kit will give you all the outputs which you can drop into this canvas (It’s fully self-guided). Start here.
Blank Template (Copy‑Paste):
Level | Definition | Your Brand |
---|---|---|
1 — Saying It | Taglines, slogans, claims | |
2 — Proving It | Testimonials, case studies, measurable results | |
3 — Being It | Decisions that cost real money/time/risk | |
4 — Owning It | Business model engineered around one mental territory |
Position | What | Niche | USP | “I help…” Line |
---|---|---|---|---|
Get the canvas as an editable Google Doc here.
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.