I don’t believe in experts, and neither should you.

In a world captivated by expertise, it might seem audacious, even reckless, to question the value of being an “expert.”

Yet, calling oneself an expert can be as limiting as it is empowering. It implies an endpoint to learning, a belief that there’s nothing left to explore.

Worse, it can inflate egos and create an unyielding attachment to one’s own ideas, stifling curiosity, adaptability, and growth.

In creative fields like marketing, branding, and business strategy—where the rules are fluid and driven by perception rather than physical laws—positioning oneself as an “expert” is not only misguided but potentially detrimental.

Atul Gawande’s TED Talk on coaching provides a compelling case study. Gawande, a renowned surgeon, had plateaued in his skills until he sought the guidance of a coach.

He’d thought his expertise made him self-sufficient, but external feedback revealed blind spots he couldn’t see. Through coaching, he re-ignited his learning curve, reducing surgical complications by fine-tuning details he had long overlooked.

Gawande’s experience points to a humbling truth: we all have limits, and growth requires continual reflection and adjustment, not a static claim of expertise.

The “Expert Delusion” and the Illusion of Mastery

When we start identifying as experts, we often become prisoners to our own perceived knowledge. Psychologists call this the Dunning-Kruger effect, where confidence in one’s abilities ironically grows with a lack of real understanding.

This leads to what some term “ego-attachment,” in which self-worth becomes tangled with our “expertise.” New perspectives get blocked out as we cling to what we think we know.

Studies show that professionals who adopt a “beginner’s mindset,” a concept from Zen Buddhism, are more adaptable and open to learning than those tied to a fixed identity as an expert.

The Limits of “Expertise” in Creative Fields

Doctors and athletes operate within clear biological and physical boundaries, where expertise has tangible outcomes.

But in marketing, sales, and branding, the only constant is change. Success here is about perception, culture, and psychology—ever-shifting landscapes that don’t lend themselves to rigid expertise.

As David Epstein argues in “Range,” generalists often outperform specialists in complex, unpredictable fields. Steve Jobs, for instance, was curious about calligraphy, Zen, and human-centered design—diverse influences that made him an innovator. Here, it’s curiosity, not a narrow claim of expertise, that leads to success.

Corporate Silos and the “Elephant in the Room”

In corporate settings, there’s a relentless drive to codify skills and box them into defined roles. This obsession with compartmentalization leads to what I call the “elephant in the room” problem.

Like the old fable, where blind men each touch one part of an elephant and think they understand the whole, corporate “experts” often view problems through their own narrow lenses.

UX becomes a box, disconnected from marketing or strategy, and real solutions get lost in translation. Instead of collaboration, people guard their territory, creating an illusion of competence while failing to solve problems holistically.

Ray Dalio’s “radical transparency” at Bridgewater Associates offers a counter-example. Dalio breaks down silos by encouraging feedback from all levels, rejecting the idea of untouchable experts.

This culture creates a shared understanding and collective responsibility—something siloed organizations sorely lack.

Embracing “Student Mode”

To avoid the trap of expertise, embrace a “student mode” mindset. Seek diverse perspectives, learn across fields, and challenge your assumptions.

In business, First Principles Thinking—breaking down complex ideas to their most basic truths—helps strip away assumptions, encouraging openness and curiosity.

Leaders like Elon Musk use this approach to build and innovate, knowing the value of foundational understanding over dogmatic expertise.

In fields with no fixed rules, the real “experts” are those who stay endlessly curious. Let’s abandon the illusion of mastery and embrace the journey of constant learning.

“Expert” is just a label; the student is forever.

---

Image: https://www.newyorker.com